Homemade envelope from a friend |
This strategy often worked as long as the student fulfilled
Part 2 of the process-- revising their writing in accordance with the
assignment and editing their grammar, punctuation and spelling, as needed.
I left teaching and moved into administration at the right
time, because any effectiveness of that strategy went out the window some years
ago. I can imagine the blank stares of
today’s youth.
“A letter?” someone asks.
“I just have to write one letter? I'll take 'T.'”
“No, I’m not talking about the alphabet. I’m
talking about a letter like snail mail.” I say.
“I’ve heard of snail mail, is it anything like email? My grandmother still uses email,” one student
says.
“My grandmother likes Messenger,” says another.
“I use Snapchat,” a
girl volunteers.
“Whatsapp is where it’s at,” the boy sitting across from the girl tells her, flirting a little bit in the process.
“I think Viber is the best,” another girl jumps into the
conversation, which is spiraling away from the issue at hand.
“I’m not talking about electronic mail,” I take another stab
at it. “I’m talking about letters like the mail carrier brings and puts in your
mailbox, the kind you take to the post office.”
Handmade envelope for a friend |
“Dr. Edgerton-Scott, we need help writing a critique of this article.
Why are you talking about something that no one understands?” another student
asks.
“Never mind,” I say. “Who wants to share their strategies
for getting started on the critique of the article you’ve read?”
“What’s a critique? they ask. “Are we going to have to
think?”
Sad isn’t it. 😢
ReplyDeleteMainly, I'm just commenting on my being old and out of touch. Even years ago, some students in teacher education didn't want to learn anything new, but most were nontraditional students who were very committed. Sometimes I am concerned if we're teaching critical thinking, or if it's "taking."
Delete“A letter?” someone asks. “I just have to write one letter? I'll take 'T.'” :) That is my favorite line!
ReplyDeleteYes, "T" is my favorite letter of the alphabet--both because my name starts with T and I just like it. Simple, yet diverse, letter.
Delete